home | resources | actions | press | contact

A Foreign Exchange of Hate:
IDRF and the American Funding of Hindutva
A Report by Sabrang Communications Pvt. Ltd. (India) / SACW (France)

Mirror Sites


Stop Corporate Sponsorship of IDRF
Faculty Petition

Project Saffron Dollar

Stop Funding Hate Campaign Responds to IDRF's Rebuttal

Frequently Asked Questions

Saffron Dollar April 2004
Campaign To Stop Funding Hate
April 24, 2004

Dear Friends,

Our heartfelt thanks to all of you for sustaining an interest in our somewhat erratic production. We are hoping to announce a completely web based newsletter in the next couple of months which will not only make the editing of this newsletter much easier but will also make it more interactive. More on that later.

This month's Saffron Dollar has, in addition to the usual quota of four items,also includes the screening schedule of the by now well known film, Final Solution, on the aftermath of the March 2002 events in Gujarat. Please scroll down and find out about the screening in your area. Please do show up andsupport the initiative.


1. What is important about this election?
2. Film screening of Final Solution in NYC
3. The Quiet Professor ploughs on
4. Action Alert: Kerala
5. Film screening schedule

1. What is important about this election ?

By the time this newsletter reaches you the electoral fortunes of various
political parties will be clear and electoral pundits would be busy inventing late swings to explain the discrepancies between opinion polls, exit polls and the final results. This is a crucial election for a number of reasons, not the least of which is that this is the first time a non Congress government at the center, a coalition at that, has completed a full term.

Whatever be the final configurations in the assemblies and in the Lok Sabha,the scramble for the tickets, the heat of electioneering, the wheeling dealing and the horse trading generate a social dynamic all of their own and throw up opportunities for the advancement for 'ideologies' in unseen ways.

Take Andhra Pradesh. The BJP stands no chance of winning any significant
proportion of the seats in Andhra Pradesh as long as the battle is fought on grounds of congressism (with its peculiar centralization of authority at the national level) and its opposition... regionalism and its better cousin federalism.

One of the reasons for Hindutva appearing to be low profile in Andhra Pradesh is that in the electoral calculus dominated by questions of contesting ideas of regionalism and subregionalism; BJP's planks, first Hindutva and now development have had little purchase among the voters. But regardless of the number of seats it wins, the BJP is likely to increase its vote percentage in many constituencies. And that is an indication of the expansion of its constituencies and, perhaps not very accurately, it also reflects the rise in the number of votaries of Hindutva.

How does Hindutva manage this? By insinuating itself into the nooks and
crannies of the main battle lines. Landlords embattled by both the reformist state and the peasant and landless workers organizations in Telangana, tribals fighting off both the bureaucratic state and wary of militant organizations, and economically or politically disenfranchised caste groups in all parts of the State. Add to this now the ambitious backward classes who are looking for political and economic opportunities which are not easily available in the Congress and the Telugu Desam.

Even if the BJP and the Telugu Desam combine performs poorly in the Andhra
elections, this is an important election for Hindutva. In the hustle bustle of the elections, it gets entrenched in new quarters. Exactly by how much, and in which parts of the country, will become clear after the electoral statistics are released. We will return to you with more on that.


2. Film showing in NYC:

On Monday March 15th, 3rd I NY, in collaboration with SALAAM Theater, organized a screening of Rakesh Sharma's documentary "Final Solution". 3rd I NY, a collective that organizes a monthly film and music salon, provides an alternative space for independent films from South Asia. In the film, Rakesh Sharma explores how the politics of hate is actively nurtured by the fascist Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and its affiliate organizations, the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP), Bajrang Dal and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

At the beginning of the screening representatives of the International
Initiative for Justice spoke about the new report (entitled "Threatened
Existence"), which presents a feminist analysis of the violence unleashed on the Muslim community, and on women in particular during the Gujarat genocide.

At the end of the screening, a representative of the Campaign to Stop Funding Hate spoke about the manner in which the right wing in India receives financial support from diasporic communities in the US and the UK. The audience was urged to be careful when donating money to relief and development projects. In conversations with several members of the audience, it became apparent that there was a lack of awareness regarding the extent to which the Hindu right wing duplicitously raises money for their fascist project by misleading the public. This lack of awareness underscores the importance of an ongoing media campaign.

3.The Quiet Professor ploughs on:

More than a decade ago, just months after the demolition of the Babri Masjid, Dr. Ram Punyani wrote an article in which he analyzed the phenomena of Hindutva as "chronic fascism". The month of April saw Dr. Punyani visit the USA. His talk at New York's Brecht Forum was illuminating as he fleshed out a theorization that he had begun with the idea of chronic fascism.

Dr. Puniyani's analysis of Hindutva as deeply systemic and enmeshed in Brahminism as what makes it capable of lasting and reinventing itself was compelling. Along with Dr. Punyani, S. C. Shah and Surabhi K. presented the process and outline of the International Initiative for Justice in Gujarat's report "Threatened Existence". The NY release of the report follows its release in India and brings to completion a international feminist response to the Gujarat Genocide. Dr. Punyani also spoke at length of the training workshops on Hindutva that he and several others have undertaken in schools and colleges, teacher training programs and youth centers.

Dr. Punyani, the quiet professor, serves as an excellent example of consistent
and dedicated work.


4. Action Alert:

Malayalam writer Sreeni Pattamthanam is facing prosecution from the Kerala government due to his critical investigative book on Mata Amritanandamayi.

Pattamthanam, one of the well-known figures of the secular rationalist movement in Kerala, wrote a book titled, “Mata Amritanandamayi: Sacred Stories and Realities.” Using court records and newspaper reports, the book states that the so-called Mata miracles are “bogus” and that the mysterious deaths around her ashram in Kollam ought to be investigated.

Based on complaints filed by Mata officials, the ruling United Democratic Front government is now initiating moves to prosecute Pattamthanam. The state government’s move is all the more surprising given that the Mata ashram is seeking prosecution on the ground of “hurting religious sentiments," although it is registered as a welfare/development organization!

Please sign on to the petition at or visit to send a letter to the chief minister, A. K. Anthony, to counter this latest threat to intellectual freedom.

5. Film screening schedule:

Rakesh Sharma will be touring the USA between April 25th and May 8th with his film Final Solution. The following is his __almost__ final schedule:

For more details send email to or

The FINAL SOLUTION by Rakesh Sharma.
Award winning (Berlin Film Festival, Hong Kong Festival) feature length
documentary on the current status in Gujarat after the 2002 pogrom.

April 25th -- Sunday -- Oberlin College -- Ohio
April 26th -- Monday -- Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh
April 27th -- Tuesday -- University of Massachusetts, Amherst
April 28th -- Wednesday -- Brecht Forum, New York City
April 29th -- Thursday -- Wellesley, Boston
April 30th -- Friday -- UIUC, Urbana Champaign
May 1st -- Saturday -- Chicago -- ThirdI
May 3rd --Monday -- Houston -- U of Houston, TX
May 4th -- Tuesday -- U of Texas, Austin
May 5th -- Wednesday -- UCLA, LA
May 6th/7th/8th -- Thu/Fri/Sat -- Bay Area (UCSC, Stanford, SF)