Hindu nationalists tap immigrant guilt in U.S.
The "Hindutva" movement opposes India's secular
system. Its leaders are raising funds in America.
By Gaiutra Bahadur, Inquirer Staff Writer
Philadelphia Inquirer, Friday, January 17, 2003 original
letters to editor: firstname.lastname@example.org
| write to author: email@example.com
Ten years ago, in a small town in north India, Ashok Singhal
spearheaded the destruction of a 16th-century mosque, sparking
the worst religious riots since the country won independence.
His supporters tore down the Babri Masjid brick by brick.
A week ago, in a basement in suburban New Jersey, Singhal
courted the hearts and pocketbooks of Hindu immigrants to
the United States.
This American visit and dozens before it, critics say, are
part of a campaign to tear down India's secular political
structure - not brick by brick, but dollar by dollar.
The movement Singhal belongs to - Hindu nationalism, or Hindutva
- is rising in India. And some say it has risen with the sometimes
unwitting help of Indian Americans who have contributed millions
to charities in their native country, particularly schools
in tribal areas that the Hindu right views as key to its agenda.
Singhal's visit coincided with the end of an unprecedented
government-sponsored conference in New Delhi of prominent
Indians living abroad. The country is trying to tap into the
guilt, nostalgia and financial resources of its diaspora.
That strategy explains the unlikely spectacle of the silver-haired
leader of the World Hindu Council holding forth in the basement
of a Voorhees physician last Friday night. Sixty people listened
to a man one called "a saint in street clothes."
Two police officers stood sentinel, since there are some
for whom Singhal, whose group has reshaped Indian politics
in the last decade, conjures Hitler more than he does a saint.
The 77-year-old - an ally of Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari
Vajpayee - spoke of the ongoing effort to build a temple over
the ruins of the Babri mosque, where Hindus believe the warrior
god Ram was born.
"We need the Hindus to unite throughout the world,"
Singhal said in an interview, "... because there is a
cultural onslaught against the Hindus."
"People can understand more because of Sept. 11,"
he said. "America has suffered the first onslaught by
the jihadis. We have been suffering this onslaught for the
last 1,000 years."
According to Human Rights Watch, Singhal's group helped stoke
religious riots in Gujurat state last spring that claimed
2,000 lives, as well as attacks on Christians in 1998 and
After Singhal's speech, his host, gynecologist Veena Gandhi,
made a pitch: "$365 a year for one school. A dollar a
day, for which we can't even buy a Coke in New York. Talk
to your friends. This is our debt to our country where we
Gandhi is a leader in the U.S. offshoot of the World Hindu
Council and a coordinator for a group devoted to starting
tribal schools, the Houston-based Ekal Vidyalaya Foundation
Since the group began, Indians in the Northeast have raised
about $500,000 for 1,400 schools, most of it from the Philadelphia
region, said Sanjeev Jindal, a coordinator and a Merck scientist
He says the schools' main purpose is to combat illiteracy.
Critics say more is at stake.
"The schools... help to create a cadre of foot soldiers
to fight against the constructed enemies of Hindutva, in this
case Muslims and Christians," said Smita Narula, a senior
researcher at Human Rights Watch.
She said more tribal people took part in last year's Gujurat
riots than ever before in the state's history of religious!
tensions - a fact viewed by many as a sign of Hindutva's success
in areas where Christian missionaries once held sway.
Gandhi dismissed critics of the schools, saying, "They
find this an obstacle to the spreading of their own religion."
She said the Hindutva agenda was not meant to exclude Muslims,
Christians, or other religious minorities: "Hindus have
always taken a beating because we are supposed to forgive...
. You cannot be tolerant to the point of being a coward."
A report last year by a group of activists - the Foreign
Exchange of Hate - revealed that the bulk of $5 million raised
by one U.S.-based charity for relief and development projects
in India went to a network of Hindu nationalist groups - including
the Ekal Vidyalaya schools.
It came largely from unsuspecting workers with origins in
India and from U.S. employers providing matching funds.
Just as many contributors did not realize how their dollars
were being used, members of Hindutva groups here seem to join
for reasons different from their
counterparts in India.
"There's a whole generation of people who emigrated
out - sort of 'brain drain' types - who feel guilty for having
left India," said Gautam Ghosh, an assistant professor
of anthropology at the University of Pennsylvania.
The dozens gathered in Gandhi's basement are battling cultural
loss in a nation where they are a minority. The World Hindu
Council hooks them on heritage, with 14 U.S. chapters that
run summer camps, cultural centers and temples.
That was how Jindal, the Merck employee, got involved.
"I thought it was a neat project, and I wanted to volunteer
my time," he said. "It would be a shock to me that
these kids are being taught to hate Muslims or Christians
- and to the extent that they should go and become soldiers.
Nothing would shock me more if that would be the case."